Castor Troy wrote:I hate it when people bash a video just for the source/song being used and not giving any criticism about the actual editing.

sometimes that is not fair, but sometimes it goes by the saying 'no news is good news' or 'some things are better left unsaid'.
like on a few first videos I've reviewed (when the other has obviously since improved) I simply might comment 'I didn't like the concept', I don't want to go into his editing style as it's obviously changed since then. Some things are better left unsaid.
Other times (mostly on average videos) I may not have words to describe how INCREDIBLY mediocre it is, most of these follow the guides to a 'T' leaveing no enginuity or problems. For stuff like this I comment on everything/ anything but the editing style as well. No news is good news.