Well I kinda guessed who edited each track with just watching
. Since I know each other's editing style and such.
One thing I want to point out as a general issue. This song is in the fast paced category and a lot of the tracks kinda draged here, not keeping up with the song and making some serious synch errors that kinda killed the flow in some of the tracks (more info below).
I will break it up in segments as well.
Track 1: it was fairly obvious Lok did this one
. IMO the best track of the MEP, great starter, it had what it needs to hook up someone to keep watching. Only bad thing was the quality with the Hajime no Ippo footage (and kinda felt out of place comparing it to the other sources). Editing wise: was really good IMO.
Track 2: mmmmm I remember beta testing this track months ago. Can't remember what I actually said to Antoine, but he lacked synching and speed, lyric synch is not enough with this kind of songs.
Track 3: I had my doubts with this one, it started good, it synched what it needed to synch but it got a bit repetitive later on.
Track 4: This could have been clearly my second fav track. Hope you can fix that issue with the quality O.O. Editing wise this was good as well IMO.
Track 5: My general issue pointed out in the begining of my post was mostly because of this track. I mean it was like this: "cool, it started fast as it needed" then "wtf? why you slowed down?" then "good again" then "slowed down again killing the flow" and so on... as Kalium said, it needed consistency.
Track 6: good track, kinda dragged down when the guitar started. But the solid editing of Shouri is well showed here. When the guitar started is when my complain on keeping up with the song appears too. Other than that, nice track
Transition between Track 6 and 7: ouch... that didn't fit IMO
Track 7: I really couldn't indentify Tri-kun's editing style here. No offence but thats not the Tri-kun I know lol. Why you missed the drum beats at the begining? cause thats what it seemed like you were trying to synch. The rest looked like out of flow.
Track 8: gah why Zero Maverick still uses those rectangles X__X? here is the only track that, even though it wasn't fast paced, it seemed like it was in some harmony with the song... except for some beats that screamed to be synched to. Other than that, good track.
Track 9: much better than your other, this has the Tri-mark in it
. Had the same problem with the beats at the begining as track 7. Subaru using the chip scene was way too long. The rest looked fine. I would have liked more hard synch in the end, but meh
.
Overall, good for a first Studio MEP. Its really cool to see how different the editing is as a whole in the MEP (either good or bad). But yeah, needed some more techincal work and some more smashing power if you can call it that
.
3.5/5
