Chouji's Last Stand AMV

[Dangan]

This is the second video of my G.E Project, the details are all on the link.

Enjoy.

And i hope DarkConfusion reviews it again ^^

http://www.animemusicvideos.org/members ... p?v=141051

Dangan

[Nunchuck]

For the love of god... cut out the sub titles... 1/5

[Dangan]

For the love of god... cut out the sub titles... 1/5

someone has already said that in my previous topic, and i need to figure out the program used to get rid of them.


what does it matter if the subs are in there for this AMV anyways? you cant tell what they're saying if they arnt there and seeing what they're saying adds emphasis to somber moments in an AMV

[Szwagier]

what does it matter if the subs are in there for this AMV anyways? you cant tell what they're saying if they arnt there and seeing what they're saying adds emphasis to somber moments in an AMV

The amv is something that have hard time from the start - you are combining anime with song that (in creators idea) wasn't meant for the actual footage. But that's not all, You actually want the viewer's to believe that the song and the anime is one entity here.
Now, when you add subtitles you do three things, which are a complete disaster for the video:

1) You tell your viewer something like - "Hey It isn't actually one, look :. That was the dialogue that was in anime in that moment, not what lyrics show now in the song". So you intentionally break the connection that you were suppose to create.

2) You distract the viewers from watching the actual vid. I for example whenever see subtitles in amv start to read them instead of watching the vid. So I cannot feel any moood you wanted to achieve, or discover any connection between music and video since I'm simply not concetrated on the vid.

3) You show that you work with fansub material. Well in many cases it's pretty obvious since the quality lets people know about it. but since the site etiquette is against fansubs you should at least pretend that it isn't from fansubbed footage by cutting thos damn subs.
I hope that will make you understand why subs are something that shouldn't be left alone

[Dangan]

what does it matter if the subs are in there for this AMV anyways? you cant tell what they're saying if they arnt there and seeing what they're saying adds emphasis to somber moments in an AMV

The amv is something that have hard time from the start - you are combining anime with song that (in creators idea) wasn't meant for the actual footage. But that's not all, You actually want the viewer's to believe that the song and the anime is one entity here.
Now, when you add subtitles you do three things, which are a complete disaster for the video:

1) You tell your viewer something like - "Hey It isn't actually one, look :. That was the dialogue that was in anime in that moment, not what lyrics show now in the song". So you intentionally break the connection that you were suppose to create.

2) You distract the viewers from watching the actual vid. I for example whenever see subtitles in amv start to read them instead of watching the vid. So I cannot feel any moood you wanted to achieve, or discover any connection between music and video since I'm simply not concetrated on the vid.

3) You show that you work with fansub material. Well in many cases it's pretty obvious since the quality lets people know about it. but since the site etiquette is against fansubs you should at least pretend that it isn't from fansubbed footage by cutting thos damn subs.
I hope that will make you understand why subs are something that shouldn't be left alone

so it sucked pretty badly then?

[Kevmaster]

I cant belive Im download this even though it has subs ~.~

*edit*

so it sucked pretty badly then?

sorry..but..yes ~.~ wasnt worth the download.

1/5

[Dangan]

I cant belive Im download this even though it has subs ~.~

*edit*

so it sucked pretty badly then?

sorry..but..yes ~.~ wasnt worth the download.

1/5

im sorry, i thought i was getting better with each AMV i made, but i guess not.

sorry i wasted your time.