Stellar performed by BECK

Shinobi34 · Post by **Shinobi34** » Sat Jun 07, 2008 7:08 am

NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT THE RATING ITS THE COMMENTS. I WANT TO KNOW WHAT ELSE MAKES IT A 2/5.

Prodigi · Post by **Prodigi** » Sat Jun 07, 2008 7:40 am

Shinobi34 wrote:NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT THE RATING ITS THE COMMENTS. I WANT TO KNOW WHAT ELSE MAKES IT A 2/5.

Everything.

Bad visual quality. Random borders that pop-up to hide the subs which are still sometimes visible when you could have (if you weren't so lazy about this video to begin with) cropped out completely be cropping the source to 16:9 and having a much cleaner look with less "what the fuck is with those borders". The lip flap in the verses was very irritating because we'd get a 5 second static shot where the only thing that's happening in the shot is someones mouth moving. The instrument synching was boring and didn't seem to match up at all. The song and anime combination didn't really match up altogether well at all. This concept has been done several times before (much better) using BECK.

I will be as polite and succinct as I can be:

Please stop bumping this thread. The only responses you have been getting, andwill be getting from here on out, will most likely be rehashing the exact same things we have been stating over and over again but you seem to keep missing the "other things" that make it a 2/5. You do not need to reply to every single post one-by-one. You do not need to update us every 12 hours with a little extra piece of information. There IS an edit button in this forum. If you DO wish to keep adding information then please feel free to do this by editing your first, or even last, post, rather than posting another useless piece of information that will simply 'accidently' (

) knock it to the top of the announcements page.

Hollow Naruto · Post by **Hollow Naruto** » Sat Jun 07, 2008 9:54 am

I think that the new vid looks like you gave a damn. You really should upgrade to some DVD's though fansubs will never get you the picture perfect quality and plus you dont have to fight those damn subtitles. Even if you dont want to buy the dvds you can always rent. I can tell that you went back and made some improvements to the lyric syncs and actually sync'd the instruments. I do agree with prodigi about the first verses mouth moving scene is a little boring going toward the bridge, but 2nd verse fits well. In general I think it's a big improvement and a good video. IMO the song and anime works. and while this concept has been done many times and there are better there has been much much worse. Hmm i think if you re-make it with dvds you wouldnt catch nearly as much bad criticism.

Anyways i think i'll give v2 a 3/5 because i do think its a lot better, but i think it could be much better