A Magical Girl MEP: Glowing Enchantments (COMPLETED)

[SilverFreedoms]

New reply so you will be more aware of it

(Nope, can't let anyone else see it)

'ducks for cover' (Not perfect, but i need some guidance ...)

[CodeZTM]

2 things technically speaking. 1) Your aspect ratio is horribly off on the scenes where there were black borders. 2) Watermarks? ohnononononononono.

If you'll tell me the specific scenes you need, I will personally upload you better quality footage in MP4 format (from my dvds) that you can convert into lossy AVIs for editing that are already made to the specifications to this project.

:10-:14 - Doesn't feel very natural to the footage. I'd replace the scenes here.

Moreover, I'd recommend focusing on just one of the girls. Because otherwise, I feel like you're lacking focus in the AMV and it feels just a bit scattered. I'd go with Madoka, since she seems to have the most appropriate footage for it.

[SilverFreedoms]

2 things technically speaking. 1) Your aspect ratio is horribly off on the scenes where there were black borders. 2) Watermarks? ohnononononononono.

If you'll tell me the specific episodes you need, I will personally upload you better quality footage in MP4 format that you can convert into lossy AVIs for editing that are already made to the specifications to this project.

:10-:14 - Doesn't feel very natural to the footage. I'd replace the scenes here.

Moreover, I'd recommend focusing on just one of the girls. Because otherwise, I feel like you're lacking focus in the AMV and it feels just a bit scattered. I'd go with Madoka, since she seems to have the most appropriate footage for it.

Ahh blast ,should have gone with my gut on the aspect ratio.... i knew it was off (Apologies)

I mentioned the watermarks earlier though

[moezy-chan]

New reply so you will be more aware of it

http://www.sendspace.com/file/ecupbx

'ducks for cover' (Not perfect, but i need some guidance ...)

I like it, but one thing that stuck out to me, besides the logo...was that this MEP was meant to focus on just one character and you focused on 3 of them. I can see the song fitting Madoka very well, especially with the final episode but I don't see it fitting Sayaka and Mami too well. If you were to focus on Madoka I think your part would look so much more amazing. Editing wise it looks great! Also, can't remember if it was from the anime or not, but the AR at 0:14 looks off. Besides that great work!

[SilverFreedoms]

New reply so you will be more aware of it

http://www.sendspace.com/file/ecupbx

'ducks for cover' (Not perfect, but i need some guidance ...)

I like it, but one thing that stuck out to me, besides the logo...was that this MEP was meant to focus on just one character and you focused on 3 of them. I can see the song fitting Madoka very well, especially with the final episode but I don't see it fitting Sayaka and Mami too well. If you were to focus on Madoka I think your part would look so much more amazing. Editing wise it looks great! Also, can't remember if it was from the anime or not, but the AR at 0:14 looks off. Besides that great work!

Funny story

Out of my crazy lack of decision....I have taken a crack at this 4 times

Mami Yellow
Sayaka Blue
Madoka Pink

and Rainbow combo of all 3 (And thanks ^^)

Taking another crack at it

[hamstar138]

oh wow, everyone got to this way before me. (this is what I get for having a Pirate's Marathon today and helping my mom with her class room (school teacher)). Well from looking at your part I will agree, logo is for sure a no because people get distracted by this. Also I would agree with everyone else the editing is nice but I also felt it went all over the place because you focused on Sayaka, Maimi and Madoka. I would agree with everyone else to try to focus on one and Madoka might be the best choice.

[SilverFreedoms]

oh wow, everyone got to this way before me. (this is what I get for having a Pirate's Marathon today and helping my mom with her class room (school teacher)). Well from looking at your part I will agree, logo is for sure a no because people get distracted by this. Also I would agree with everyone else the editing is nice but I also felt it went all over the place because you focused on Sayaka, Maimi and Madoka. I would agree with everyone else to try to focus on one and Madoka might be the best choice.

Is this not due at the end of August ? Or did I imagine that ?

[hamstar138]

oh wow, everyone got to this way before me. (this is what I get for having a Pirate's Marathon today and helping my mom with her class room (school teacher)). Well from looking at your part I will agree, logo is for sure a no because people get distracted by this. Also I would agree with everyone else the editing is nice but I also felt it went all over the place because you focused on Sayaka, Maimi and Madoka. I would agree with everyone else to try to focus on one and Madoka might be the best choice.

Is this not due at the end of August ? Or did I imagine that ?

So far yes. But I also haven't received two betas and I haven't gotten Kaze's updated one. So I am decided wether or not to extend the date due to the end of next month. I'm going back to college soon in the beginning of September so it'll be harder for me to work on this.

[hamstar138]

(accidental double post please ignore)

[CodeZTM]

If you have to delay it into September, but need help with compiling it together, I can easily offer my services.