Lucid Nightmare - The Halloween MEP [Compiling]
- FadingSundown
- Joined: Mon Jan 17, 2011 4:17 pm
- Location: The Netherlands
- Contact:
Re: The Halloween MEP : [7/7 Tracks Taken] [Final Due: Oct
Beta testing:
Kireblue (opening): It think the colours are too light. It gives me a really daytimish feeling. It is okay if it is bright in the beginning, but it would be better if it turned darker when we go to the house scene and after that. Also, the text is a bit too obvious, I dont know if you use AAE, but if you do, maybe you could put a little bit of roughen edge on it, that would make the text more unrefined, less font like (I am really bad with explaining things, so if you dont follow, im completely at fault).
Kireblue (ending): I like the pictures in the frames, though I think the beginning is still too bright. I still get that daytime feeling. Maybe you could mask out the frame of the painting too and make the background darker. Also, does your part seem to be in a bad quality, or is it just me ><?
Code: I have to say it, I love the zombie with 'am I scaring you tonight' part! At 0:08 you have a really loud beat (from the drum) and maybe it would be nice if you hit it. Maybe you could do a zoom-in transition at 0:21, that might look good :3. Also, maybe a little bit of more contrast xD.
Aimo: I love it! The colours look much more intense now, just like I had in mind! Nothing more to add, reallly good final :3!
Kazemon: Uhm, some of this feedback I kind of quote from my previous feedback on your beta, because I can still see it (you never really answered on my feedback, so I dont know if you overread it or if you kept it the way it was). At 0:08 and 0:49 the movement looks unnatural, I dont know the anime so I dont know if it was like that or if you did it. I'm not really a fan of 2 layers on top of eachother (for example at 0:18 and 0:31) but I guess that is just me. Love the ending though. Also, just like I said to Aimo, I think your part could use more contrast to intensify the colours.
Sorry for my inactivity xD. I had to be a last-minute drop in for a MEP from the studio im in, so I worked in that instead of posting here ><. I put my (final?) beta on the sheet. I removed the lip-flip flap at 0:33. I replaced the lips by masking, so if the movement is a bit off, tell me. For the opening/ending I will put a zip in the sheet tomorrow or the day after. Yumekui merry sometimes has a rather 'childish' drawing style, so most pictures I can find arent creepy but with donuts ><.
Kireblue (opening): It think the colours are too light. It gives me a really daytimish feeling. It is okay if it is bright in the beginning, but it would be better if it turned darker when we go to the house scene and after that. Also, the text is a bit too obvious, I dont know if you use AAE, but if you do, maybe you could put a little bit of roughen edge on it, that would make the text more unrefined, less font like (I am really bad with explaining things, so if you dont follow, im completely at fault).
Kireblue (ending): I like the pictures in the frames, though I think the beginning is still too bright. I still get that daytime feeling. Maybe you could mask out the frame of the painting too and make the background darker. Also, does your part seem to be in a bad quality, or is it just me ><?
Code: I have to say it, I love the zombie with 'am I scaring you tonight' part! At 0:08 you have a really loud beat (from the drum) and maybe it would be nice if you hit it. Maybe you could do a zoom-in transition at 0:21, that might look good :3. Also, maybe a little bit of more contrast xD.
Aimo: I love it! The colours look much more intense now, just like I had in mind! Nothing more to add, reallly good final :3!
Kazemon: Uhm, some of this feedback I kind of quote from my previous feedback on your beta, because I can still see it (you never really answered on my feedback, so I dont know if you overread it or if you kept it the way it was). At 0:08 and 0:49 the movement looks unnatural, I dont know the anime so I dont know if it was like that or if you did it. I'm not really a fan of 2 layers on top of eachother (for example at 0:18 and 0:31) but I guess that is just me. Love the ending though. Also, just like I said to Aimo, I think your part could use more contrast to intensify the colours.
Sorry for my inactivity xD. I had to be a last-minute drop in for a MEP from the studio im in, so I worked in that instead of posting here ><. I put my (final?) beta on the sheet. I removed the lip-flip flap at 0:33. I replaced the lips by masking, so if the movement is a bit off, tell me. For the opening/ending I will put a zip in the sheet tomorrow or the day after. Yumekui merry sometimes has a rather 'childish' drawing style, so most pictures I can find arent creepy but with donuts ><.
- CodeZTM
- Spin Me Round
- Joined: Fri Mar 03, 2006 6:13 pm
- Status: Flapping Lips
- Location: Arkansas
- Contact:
Re: The Halloween MEP : [7/7 Tracks Taken] [Final Due: Oct
Thank you very much for all your feedback throughout the whole MEP FS. Very helpful.
AT the same time, I also want to thank you for your final version. EDIT: I'll watch it soon. Misread your post and thought you had an actual final. XD
EDIT: Looks pretty good in my opinion. Nothing really stood out to me that needed fixing. Nice job on lip syncing the first bit, looks much better now. :3 So I'm good getting a final out of this one.
AT the same time, I also want to thank you for your final version. EDIT: I'll watch it soon. Misread your post and thought you had an actual final. XD
EDIT: Looks pretty good in my opinion. Nothing really stood out to me that needed fixing. Nice job on lip syncing the first bit, looks much better now. :3 So I'm good getting a final out of this one.
- AimoAio
- Being elegantly...lazy
- Joined: Sun Mar 16, 2008 12:19 pm
- Location: Somewhere
- Contact:
Re: The Halloween MEP : [7/7 Tracks Taken] [Final Due: Oct
Merry likes her donuts. XD You might be better off just taking screencaps off the show itself.FadingSundown wrote:Yumekui merry sometimes has a rather 'childish' drawing style, so most pictures I can find arent creepy but with donuts ><.
Also I agree with Code about your beta, it looks ready to be a final but are you sure you don't want to add something at 0:15 to sync the background vocals there? Just the scene there that was synced to the main vocals feels a little long. Maybe just add a small overlay?
- Kireblue
- Forum Admin
- Joined: Tue Mar 06, 2007 10:44 pm
- Location: Atlanta, Georgia
- Contact:
Re: The Halloween MEP : [7/7 Tracks Taken] [Final Due: Oct
Don't worry about finding stills. I've already taken all the stills that I need from the beta that you uploded a while ago. I just need the footage.FadingSundown wrote: Yumekui merry sometimes has a rather 'childish' drawing style, so most pictures I can find arent creepy but with donuts ><.
- Kireblue
- Forum Admin
- Joined: Tue Mar 06, 2007 10:44 pm
- Location: Atlanta, Georgia
- Contact:
Re: The Halloween MEP : [7/7 Tracks Taken] [Final Due: Oct
FadingSundown, nevermind about the footage. I just downloaded the clean OP of the Yumekui Merry, and it has all the scenes that I need.kireblue wrote:Don't worry about finding stills. I've already taken all the stills that I need from the beta that you uploded a while ago. I just need the footage.FadingSundown wrote: Yumekui merry sometimes has a rather 'childish' drawing style, so most pictures I can find arent creepy but with donuts ><.
Edit: I just added a new beta for track 1. If no one has any objections to it, then it can be the final.
- FadingSundown
- Joined: Mon Jan 17, 2011 4:17 pm
- Location: The Netherlands
- Contact:
Re: The Halloween MEP : [7/7 Tracks Taken] [Final Due: Oct
Thank you so much kireblue :3! Yumekui Merry OP is a really good idea yeah, I didnt know the clean OP excisted already ><. Thanks again, Kire ^^!
I dont quite understand by what you mean with this. Do you mean that i could put a moving overlay on top of that that moves to make it more interesting or do you mean something else xD?AimoAio wrote:
Also I agree with Code about your beta, it looks ready to be a final but are you sure you don't want to add something at 0:15 to sync the background vocals there? Just the scene there that was synced to the main vocals feels a little long. Maybe just add a small overlay?
- AimoAio
- Being elegantly...lazy
- Joined: Sun Mar 16, 2008 12:19 pm
- Location: Somewhere
- Contact:
Re: The Halloween MEP : [7/7 Tracks Taken] [Final Due: Oct
Yeah something like that, it just feels like something was missing that's all.FadingSundown wrote:I dont quite understand by what you mean with this. Do you mean that i could put a moving overlay on top of that that moves to make it more interesting or do you mean something else xD?AimoAio wrote:
Also I agree with Code about your beta, it looks ready to be a final but are you sure you don't want to add something at 0:15 to sync the background vocals there? Just the scene there that was synced to the main vocals feels a little long. Maybe just add a small overlay?
- CodeZTM
- Spin Me Round
- Joined: Fri Mar 03, 2006 6:13 pm
- Status: Flapping Lips
- Location: Arkansas
- Contact:
Re: The Halloween MEP : [7/7 Tracks Taken] [Final Due: Oct
I love it kire! You made the first transition for my bit very easy too. :3 /hugs
Maybe some kind of creepy overlay on the last part in the frame? Like a red/dark blue just to make them all seem more uniform? Aimo/FS will probably have a good idea on that if it's something that should be done or not.
Otherwise, nicely done.
Maybe some kind of creepy overlay on the last part in the frame? Like a red/dark blue just to make them all seem more uniform? Aimo/FS will probably have a good idea on that if it's something that should be done or not.
Otherwise, nicely done.
- FadingSundown
- Joined: Mon Jan 17, 2011 4:17 pm
- Location: The Netherlands
- Contact:
Re: The Halloween MEP : [7/7 Tracks Taken] [Final Due: Oct
Kireblue: I love the way you darkened the beginning because it looks really creepy now :3! For the type of font you used, I dont especially like it. Here are a few suggestions of fonts I think could be better instead of the font you're using now:
I personally like seedy motel, and Im not sure whether you should use payday, because it is in 'boxes' so that probably wont look good in the pictures. These fonts are just suggestions ofcourse xD.
Also, I think that the footage for Code's track is too light. And you may want to add a little contrast to the footage in the frame (except Aimo's footage), that'll intensify the colors (im sorry if I am repeating myself alot about contrast). The background behind the frame is still a bit too light, so you could use an overlay such as Code suggested to not only give it all the same tint, but also darken it all might be a good idea. Or, you can darken it the same way as you in beginning, that could give it a creepier look.
Spoiler :
Also, I think that the footage for Code's track is too light. And you may want to add a little contrast to the footage in the frame (except Aimo's footage), that'll intensify the colors (im sorry if I am repeating myself alot about contrast). The background behind the frame is still a bit too light, so you could use an overlay such as Code suggested to not only give it all the same tint, but also darken it all might be a good idea. Or, you can darken it the same way as you in beginning, that could give it a creepier look.
- Kireblue
- Forum Admin
- Joined: Tue Mar 06, 2007 10:44 pm
- Location: Atlanta, Georgia
- Contact:
Re: The Halloween MEP : [7/7 Tracks Taken] [Final Due: Oct
I actually really like the bloody font that I used. Does anyone else think that I should change it? If everyone wants me to, I can easily make the adjustment.FadingSundown wrote:Kireblue: I love the way you darkened the beginning because it looks really creepy now :3! For the type of font you used, I dont especially like it. Here are a few suggestions of fonts I think could be better instead of the font you're using now:I personally like seedy motel, and Im not sure whether you should use payday, because it is in 'boxes' so that probably wont look good in the pictures. These fonts are just suggestions ofcourse xD.Spoiler :
Also, I think that the footage for Code's track is too light. And you may want to add a little contrast to the footage in the frame (except Aimo's footage), that'll intensify the colors (im sorry if I am repeating myself alot about contrast). The background behind the frame is still a bit too light, so you could use an overlay such as Code suggested to not only give it all the same tint, but also darken it all might be a good idea. Or, you can darken it the same way as you in beginning, that could give it a creepier look.
In terms of background behind the frame, I'll adjust it some more. And I'll darken the inside footage a bit a well.