Project NeoEditor [Results - Aug 11, 2010 01:00 AM CST]

[Angelyco]

It wasn't just because it was shinkai... That's fucking stupid, I could care less about what source is used.

edit: Also notice that angelyco's got my lowest score of 42, because I thought it was just bad, I think she deserved the elemination this round far more then you.

Strangely, I'm not offended by that at all. I really disliked this round's theme and had NO motivation to do it, so in the end I just picked something I thought I could work with and edited to it. I would have rather at least submitted something, fully knowing I might be eliminated, than just dropped.

[CodeZTM]

Oh, and because there seems to be [AHHH, MY PM BOX] some resentment regarding scores, please send me a pm if you'd like a detailed analysis/breakdown. Nya, I already sent you yours from mine.

I'll leave it up to the other judges to answer their own reasons for their scores.

[Angelyco]

Also, I LOVE this theme and actually look forward to editing for the first time this contest.

[NS]

You people get offended (or not) even though most of you know you only spent like the last minute of time allowed editing these, or didn't really feel good about the theme... That's the thing, of course you have disadvantages so these videos aren't gonna be what you want them to be. And I suppose I could use nicer words...but it doesn't really matter. This competition setting doesn't fully say what we think about one's talents as an editor as a whole. it really only speaks to your flexibility.... wtf, I'm really tired. Whatever, idk what I'm trying to say. But yah, I'm still really surprised angelyco got higer scores then nya sorry, and I only like JUST realize which video ange's was, so I'm still kinda surprised.

[Ileia]

If Round 4 is meme, I hope that I don't win just for the sake of a C-C-C-COMBO BREAKER!!!!

I'm coo with being able to predict the future.


And to address a comment I keep getting about how I just edited the music to the source and didn't reinvent it at all...

Spoiler :

Let's consider what happened in the video:

-Added a double rainbow in the sky, like the original video, for characters to see and comment on.
-But unlike in the original video, I had the double rainbow join with the angel as seen here:


-They fight the double rainbow angel, also unlike the original video, yet still contains the "double rainbow" element.

If I had just repeated the opening "introduction" of the double rainbow for the whole video, THEN it would've been "just editing to the music and not reinventing." I'm okay with not being the top scorer this round (it's all coo as long as I wasn't DQ'd D:), but to those saying that I didn't follow the theme at all, I say bullshit.

[Kitsuner]

What I mean by this is that the judges should be able to get an emotional response from the video. If your last day is doing fun things, we should be able to feel the fun behind it. If your last day is being with the one that you love, then we should feel some romance feeling from it. If your last day is murdering everybody in sight, we should be able to feel the insanity.ast day to do everything they wanted to do in life, having as much fun as possible. The video shows characters

I think you accidentally part of your post. Regardless, it confirms that achieving the reaction I want will get me the points I need.

[MycathatesyouAMV]

Honestly this sounds like the easiest theme to me so far

[Ileia]

/me turns in this video:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bV_8W0uXc3A

Edit:

Wait, I've done this myself:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XY7PTz7QbQA

/me turns in THIS video

[CodeZTM]

Oh, and to answer a question that Ileia and Lantis seem to have brought up, Live Action footage is fine.

[gotegenks]

GTFO.

who's the tool that's gonna use the nickelback or kris allen songs?