AC-Cubed 2006 AMV Contest

Announcement & discussion of Anime Music Video contests
Forum rules
Coordinators who fail to maintain necessary communication with entrants, or provide timely updates on results may be barred from announcing future events.
eyevocal
Joined: Sun Jun 03, 2001 5:32 pm
Org Profile

Re: The Official Report and Winners List

Post by eyevocal » Tue Nov 21, 2006 7:56 pm

Haunter103 wrote:Whaaat? That's bull$#*^! I demand a recount! :roll:
Seriously though I wasn't expecting that at all. As far as originality goes, I really thought a chobits horror and noise video would have topped me. And there were a lot of other entries that looked like they had a lot more effort put into them than mine did. Frankly, I put a lot more effort into my other entry which was disqualified even :\
That's how things go sometimes. Ever notice how some of the most primitive rock songs are some of the most enduring? Also, I liked the Chobits clip a lot. Despite the technical problems we had trying to convert the video file to MPEG2, I insisted on showing it; I even phoned Todd during the con to get him to FTP us a DVD-ready version, but we couldn't work it in in time. However, the other judges, almost none of whom are mutants like me, didn't like it as much. Got a few comments along the lines of "Ow!" after it was over at the judging.
Haunter103 wrote:And thanks alot, I wasn't even planning to make an org entry for Marineland (Too much like an AMV Hell clip; I don't like making separate entries for those) but then you had to go handing out awards for stuff and now I have no choice >:|. bastid. Well, you'll have to make due with the You tube version, since my own computer wont start turn on at the moment (posting using family computer) and can't upload it.
Well, here's hoping you do once the machine works again.
Haunter103 wrote:That aside, it really was a great showing, and the audience was very responsive, and didn't loose enthusiasm as the evening went on.
eyevocal wrote:That's right; none of this "turn up at the con to claim it or lose it" crap here.
But if you do turn up you don't get anything anyway? I can only assume that you didn't have the certificates made up or something, because when you didn't call us up to the stage to receive awards, I wasn't able to stick around and inquire about it since I had to get going in order to be home sometime before midnight @_@. It's not a big deal or anything, I'm just saying that if you did have the awards there, you could have saved yourself some postage by letting us know (I know at least Kristyrat was in attendance as well, can't speak for any other winners :P)
I was hoping to make this a "pause the program to give out prizes" type of showing, but we didn't have the packages together because all the con staff were hopping around like maniacs running the con, including me; otherwise, I would have collated everything myself and had it on hand. Apart from the AMV contest, I was also handling panels and various tasks, including picking up garbage in the halls (the hotel didn't have enough trash cans to handle us) and helping with different emergencies that came up. Cons are kind of like swans: They appear to move pretty smoothly on the surface of the water, but look underneath and you'll see paddling like mad. Besides, I'd say that AC Cubed 2006 was successful enough that we can easily afford the postage for these things. Next year's AMV contest improvement plans include having the rules ready earlier, having a deadline further away from the con date, and generally having things together enough to allow me to at least try to get the prize packages ready for the contest showing. Please bear with us.

Dave Watson
Still catching up on sleep.

User avatar
JudgeHolden
Joined: Mon Mar 14, 2005 8:49 am
Status: Looking at you through your window!
Location: The great white north (Minneapolis)
Org Profile

Post by JudgeHolden » Wed Nov 22, 2006 9:04 am

Maybe a list of what was played? :wink:

eyevocal
Joined: Sun Jun 03, 2001 5:32 pm
Org Profile

The Compleat AC Cubed 2006 AMV Contest Playlist

Post by eyevocal » Wed Nov 22, 2006 12:31 pm

Because the Judge insisted (and because it weas a good idea):

Here is the playlist for the AC Cubed 2006 AMV Contest, in the format of the credit screens we used (except that I originally put song titles and artists/bands on separate lines). Note that at least one of the animemusicvideos.org links (to information pages) doesn't have a download available:

Naotadammerung

"Neodammerung" by Don Davis
Anime: FLCL

Blu Harves7
--
Solitude

"We Are" by Anna Johnson
various anime

Dzierlatka Benjamin Tisnak
--
Who Do Those Azu-Girls Think They Are?

"Who Do You Think You Are?" by Spice Girls
Anime: Azumanga Daioh

Maegan Lynch
--
Tourniquet - A Naruto Tribute

"Tourniquet" by Evanescence
Anime: Naruto

Michaela McGee
--
BEST COMPOSITION
RUNNER-UP--BEST TECHNICAL

Overture Musicas

"Exodus" by Maksim Mrvica
Anime: Karas

Insomnia Studios
--
ManHunter

"Ain't No Other Man" by Christina Aguilera
Anime: Cowboy Bebop (TV and movie)

Hana no JudgeHolden Productions
--
7 Days of Summer

7 Days TV OP sequence
Anime: Natsuiro no Sunadokei

GBT Ltd
--
Broken Worlds

"This Could Be Anywhere in the World" by Alexisonfire
Anime: Fullmetal Alchemist (TV and movie)

Power Shield Alchemist Studios
--
Konoha Under Attack

"Seven Nation Army" by the White Stripes
Anime: Naruto

Mélissa Langlois
--
RUNNER-UP—MOST ORIGINAL
RUNNER-UP—BEST COMPOSITION

Panda Punk!

"Panda Punk" by Peelander Z
Anime: Panda-Z: The Robonimation

Corndog VidVids
--
Looking for Love (and a New Witch Doctor)

"Witch Doctor" by Cartoons
Anime: Fushigi Yuugi

Kumaguro's AMVs
--
As We Walk These Alternate Paths

"Move Along" by the All-American Rejects
Anime: Cutscenes from Fullmetal Alchemist games 2 & 3

Power Shield Alchemist Studios
--
"Rainy Day Man" by Jennifer Love Hewitt
Anime: Elfen Lied

Chaotic Bad-Raptor

[Searched his website and the Org, but couldn't find it. According to his entry form, it was part of a MEP.]
--
The Weapon With Emotion

"Everything Burns" by Ben Moody featuring Anastasia
Anime: Xenosaga: The Animation

Maegan Lynch
--
NON-COMPETING ENTRY

"Puedes contar conmigo" by la oreja de Van Gogh
Anime: Air (Movie)

anonymous

[The entrant has this and other vids on his personal website, which he only seems to publicize in his E-mail .sig. I'll leave it up to him to put that address here or not.]
--
BEST TECHNICAL

Crimson Memories

"Born Too Slow" by Crystal Method
Anime: Burst Angel

Visualized Nightmare Studios
--
"Enjoy the Silence" by Depeche Mode (Reinterpreted by Mike Shinoda)
Anime: Rurouni Kenshin (Samurai X) OVAs

Boris Dekovic
--
Hinata Will Triumph

"Chrono Cross ~Time's Scar~" by Yasunori Mitsuda
Anime: Naruto

Alison Jamieson
--
Ichigo vs. Byakuya

"Breaking the Habit" by Linkin Park
Anime: Bleach

Suhana Persaud
--
i am small

"Breathe Me" by Sia
Anime: Arjuna

Blurry Line Media
--
GRAND PRIZE
MOST ORIGINAL

Marine Land

Marineland Ontario Commercial
Anime: One Piece

haunter103
--
Seiji's Little Secret

"Dirty Little Secret" by the All-American Rejects
Anime: Midori Days

LC Productions
--
Swords of Moonlight

"Mitternacht"
by E Nomine
Anime: Final Fantasy VII: Last Order

Phoenix Productions
--
Fate's Scrawl

"The Hand of Fate Part 1"
by James Newton Howard
Anime: Death Note

Moonlight Soldier
--
NON-COMPETING ENTRY

Hellø Fairy

various songs/audio
Anime: Bottle Fairy and various

Doki Doki Productions
--
Schism of the Epistle to Dippy

"Epistle to Dippy" by Masonna
Anime: Chobits

Corndog VidVids

(Time: 42 seconds)

[Originally planned to play after Ichigo vs. Byakuya; got moved to near the end for technical reasons.]
--
[Last-minute non-competing entry:]

Gravitation to Go

“Ready to Go” by Republica
Anime: Gravitation

SynMedia

And that's it.

Dave Watson
Dialup sucks almost as hard as poverty.

Edit, 2006 12 12: Changed Marine Land link to Org page.
Last edited by eyevocal on Tue Dec 12, 2006 12:25 am, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Shouri no Hana
Joined: Sat May 20, 2006 12:33 pm
Location: Capital of Canada
Org Profile

Post by Shouri no Hana » Wed Nov 22, 2006 8:32 pm

And as if running around in reality isn't enough...sigh...

Anyway, I'm here to supply the YouTube link to my AMV, 'Tourinquet -A Naruto Tribute-'

The direct will come about on the weekend, I think...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z_ZXioWjvTQ

User avatar
DJ_Izumi
Joined: Wed Oct 03, 2001 8:29 am
Location: Canada
Contact:
Org Profile

Post by DJ_Izumi » Thu Nov 23, 2006 7:31 pm

Either next year we (I) don't do anything on DVD, or everyone has to submit NTSC 4:3 (no anamorphic) complaint DVD mpegs with MP2 audio. ;_;

Someone managed to submit a PAL DVD compliant vidoe. o.o;;;
Image

User avatar
Fall_Child42
has a rock
Joined: Wed Aug 11, 2004 6:32 pm
Status: Veloci-tossin' to the max!
Location: Jurassic Park
Org Profile

Post by Fall_Child42 » Thu Nov 23, 2006 9:52 pm

DJ_Izumi wrote:Either next year we (I) don't do anything on DVD,
I Support this idea, for if we have a laptop for play back, setting up a VLC playlist is very simple to do, and it allows for Really high quality (but small) h.264 videos.
Image

User avatar
DJ_Izumi
Joined: Wed Oct 03, 2001 8:29 am
Location: Canada
Contact:
Org Profile

Post by DJ_Izumi » Thu Nov 23, 2006 9:57 pm

Honest to god, every video room at AC^3 is run by laptops (or desktops when not available) The AMV contest and I think the flash/underground animation panel were done on DVD. I dunno about the animation thingy, we just put a DVD there and the guy had the rest done.

Also, it allows our video rooms to count down till the next episode and next year they'll even announce what shows next during that time as well. That can be done on DVD but it requires a lot more effort that I'm just not willing to do.

With AMVs, it's a bigger pain than converting fansubs to DVD. Fansubs are typically PRETTY uniform. Their resolutions are predictable and are their frame rates fall within expected standards. (Usually) With the AMVs, I had everything from really good looking h264 tossed at me to 30.00fps WMVs to a PAL DVD compliant video to a DVD compliant video that for reason reason was muxed with MP3 audio instead of MP2. Some were DVD compliant with AC3 instead of MP2. One video had uncompressed audio and the audio took up more space than the video! Some were strangely interlaced even though they were made from fansubs... I mean WOW. X_@

I'll agree to DVD agian if all submissions have to be made compliant by the editor and we just reject the ones that arn't encoded correctly. It's a lot easier to make 30 people each make one video compliant than make one person make 30 videos compliant. Otherwise, Laptops. |:

Also, maybe I've only realized this now since I've never been involved in a the technical end of a contest this deeply before. But why does it seem most people don't even make high quality convention-quality encodes of their projects? o_____o Maybe... 25% of people did, the rest sent me what would really be called 'distro quality'. o.O
Image

eyevocal
Joined: Sun Jun 03, 2001 5:32 pm
Org Profile

Post by eyevocal » Sun Nov 26, 2006 11:51 pm

DJ_Izumi wrote:I'll agree to DVD agian if all submissions have to be made compliant by the editor and we just reject the ones that arn't encoded correctly. It's a lot easier to make 30 people each make one video compliant than make one person make 30 videos compliant. Otherwise, Laptops. |:

Also, maybe I've only realized this now since I've never been involved in a the technical end of a contest this deeply before. But why does it seem most people don't even make high quality convention-quality encodes of their projects? o_____o Maybe... 25% of people did, the rest sent me what would really be called 'distro quality'. o.O
Since getting everybody to submit in this format is very unlikely to happen, then it looks like I'll be owning up to the fact that I made a pretty big mistake my first year of running the contest: Tying up the tech's time with something that turned out to complicate things unnecessarily. So, here and now, I want to take the time to apologize to Ashley/Izumi and anybody else who I inconvenienced with my big piece of overambition. While I'll still be running the contest next year (I liked doing it, and otherwise did quite well), I will learn from my mistakes and run the contest showing off a computer next year. The proposed no-more-WMV-submissions rule amendment will likely still stand; let's see what happens when the time to start pulling AC Cubed 2007 together comes.

Dave Watson
AC Cubed 2006 AMV Contest Wrangled (and rightly so).
Last edited by eyevocal on Sun Nov 26, 2006 11:54 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
DJ_Izumi
Joined: Wed Oct 03, 2001 8:29 am
Location: Canada
Contact:
Org Profile

Post by DJ_Izumi » Sun Nov 26, 2006 11:53 pm

Actually you could probably find someone else to deal with the DVD task exclusively who's not dealing with video rooms and other hubbub around the con in the last 2 weeks before the con. It's also possible there's a more straight forward method to authoring DVDs that I'm not using, I mostly adapted from doing VCDs. It's possible some of the all-in-one software could do a better job than my more hands on approach to the encoding and such.
Image

eyevocal
Joined: Sun Jun 03, 2001 5:32 pm
Org Profile

Post by eyevocal » Mon Nov 27, 2006 12:07 am

DJ_Izumi wrote:Actually you could probably find someone else to deal with the DVD task exclusively who's not dealing with video rooms and other hubbub around the con in the last 2 weeks before the con. It's also possible there's a more straight forward method to authoring DVDs that I'm not using, I mostly adapted from doing VCDs. It's possible some of the all-in-one software could do a better job than my more hands on approach to the encoding and such.
Well, if you want to take a crack at finding all-in-one software or somebody else who can do re-encoding for DVD, then it's a maybe. But the thing that showed me that maybe I should be using the tried-and-true method after all was getting Todd to resubmit the Schism video to the FTP in DVD format, which he did twice--an MPEG2 and a VOB. The MPEG worked beautifully. The VOB gave me the problems you reported having when you were trying to convert the file he originally submitted.

Also, since I've worked out several things from doing this (experience being the greatest teacher and all), one of my big plans for next year is to start the contest earlier and move the contest deadline further away from the weekend of the con. If you think this might help you out with trying to make a video DVD in 2007 and you're up for it (and not busy with other, more important tasks), then let's try again; if not, then I'm willing to let it go for the good of the contest and the con in general.

Locked

Return to “AMV Contests”