Corndog Vidvids Iron Chef - RESULTS ARE OUT!!!

[Animated]

Thanks for the 3rd place, judges! :3 This Iron Chef was a total success, organised real fast without any problem. And once again, congratulations to everyone that sent a video! (now did I realise what editors are capable of, given so little time... some entries really, really surprised me)

Now, heading straight to the real Project Editor contest!

[ngsilver]

I though I ranked right about where I expected to. Thanks for the comments ZS, that's pretty much what I was going for and I'm glad the concept made it through the editing. I wish I had more time to work on the timed star twinkles and really mask hem out via AE, but I could hardly keep it open long enough to get anything done which is why I went with some garbage mattes in premier. It was a fun challenge in the end trying to edit something that complex on my poor laptop that I really only bought for word processing. I do have another idea for this song that I may work on in the future.

I'm always a supporter of IC competitions and really I like how this one played out. Thanks for hosting y'all. Looking forward to more. Perhaps we can get other studios to jump in and host next time.

[Radical_Yue]

We're actually considering doing "guest judges" from other studios for the next one. VNS, RDS, who knows? Who would be on board for that?


And what are your thoughts on a 2nd round consisting of all the winners from the individual groups to decide the Top 3 as opposed to us just kind of deciding?

[BasharOfTheAges]

don't quite agree with some of the scores given, but I respect his decision. Congrats to everyone that won!

Remember that scores are relative - i.e. each judge probably has slightly different definitions of what a 7 or a 10 in any given category is. I know my definitions are a little different from other judges.

Given that, I was kinda surprised there was even a top 3 - these were, essentially a bunch of separate contests happening under the same rule set at the same time, not one.

[LopezAMV]

We're actually considering doing "guest judges" from other studios for the next one. VNS, RDS, who knows? Who would be on board for that?


And what are your thoughts on a 2nd round consisting of all the winners from the individual groups to decide the Top 3 as opposed to us just kind of deciding?

I'm not in another studio but I'd be on board if you'll have me that is. As for a 2nd round, Yes please

[mirkosp]

And what are your thoughts on a 2nd round consisting of all the winners from the individual groups to decide the Top 3 as opposed to us just kind of deciding?

If it actually means make a new video to a new pack of songs, sure!

[AMV_4000]

I might be interested in judging... I Have very different tastes in things.. mabeh more cbr members might be interested. If not a judge, I may want to edit again.

[Radical_Yue]

And what are your thoughts on a 2nd round consisting of all the winners from the individual groups to decide the Top 3 as opposed to us just kind of deciding?

If it actually means make a new video to a new pack of songs, sure!

I'm thinking each judge would throw 1 -2 songs into a new pack that is given to all the finalists to choose from?

[inthesto]

Chiming in to say I've filled in the scores and written in comments for the people in my group. Sorry about the delay, I'll be better about it next time (that's a lie and we all know it).

That said, next time my pool is going to have much more difficult songs. Look forward to it!

[javywhite]

We're actually considering doing "guest judges" from other studios for the next one. VNS, RDS, who knows? Who would be on board for that?


And what are your thoughts on a 2nd round consisting of all the winners from the individual groups to decide the Top 3 as opposed to us just kind of deciding?

this sounds fun