Free Opinions but more special

[The_McLaughlin]

I'd give it maybe a 6 or 7 so I guess I'll take it right in the middle and say 6.5/10 and probably overall since I've started editing again in college out of my recent videos 4th out of 6 videos.

Feel free to rip it to shreds if you need to. I think what I need to improve is some tough love as the comments I'm used to getting are "cool", and "good job man". So I figured since I don't have friends who edit maybe I can get some good feedback here on the org where there are a slew of editors who are probably way better than me, and maybe I one day too can be awesome like them if I could get a few critiques on my videos.

[pillsbury15]

Hmm... I guess 7 or 7.5 nah lets go with 7 and out of all of them I guess I'd rank it somewhere in the top 3... probably 3rd

[advent87]

If you got the time and if this is still open




I would give it between an 8 and an 8.5. Compared to my other videos it's ranked in the top 3 probably 2nd

[WolfandAngel]

Member: WolfandAngel
Title: Sword Art Online Fan-Trailer PREVIEW
Premiered: 2013-02-05
Categories: Action,Drama,Instrumental,Romance,Trailer
Song:
Mark Petrie
Prophecy Fulfilled
Anime:
Sword Art Online (TV)

A 7.5 the quality isn't the best sometimes and it doesn't really have a re-view-ability. With the rank I'm not sure because this vid is my second amv, personally I like my first one much more but that's because on that one i can see how much more i can improve it.

[Shinzui IT]

I'd rank this either 7 or 8 out of 10 and it's ranked third in my videos.

[BlindSage]

Slowly going through these, i almost forgot about this actually

[Luke0zZz]

Thanks!

[BakaOppai]

For my first AMV, I think it turned out pretty well.
Id say 7/10

[MycathatesyouAMV]

8 out of 10 and I would rank it 3rd. Thanks.

[jt_x]

I give my own track (the haruhi one) a 6/10 it's kinda crappy and I have done better in the past. I would rank it like 5th or something.
However the paradise kiss track gets a 10/10 from me . The my little monster track is also pretty good