Most Helpful Member

[Enigma]

I'll throw Shui in the ballot. When it comes down to suggesting songs and help with music in general, he's pretty much the best one to ask to.

indeed

Shui - The man of the music.

[LittleAtari]

I'll throw Shui in the ballot. When it comes down to suggesting songs and help with music in general, he's pretty much the best one to ask to.

speaking of the ballot, how is who gets to be on the ballot decided because i noticed that some of the people i wanted to nominate were not on it.

[mirkosp]

I'll throw Shui in the ballot. When it comes down to suggesting songs and help with music in general, he's pretty much the best one to ask to.

speaking of the ballot, how is who gets to be on the ballot decided because i noticed that some of the people i wanted to nominate were not on it.

Any user eligible for VCAs should be in the most helpful list, actually. When i said ballot I just meant I'd put his nick in the thread since no one recommended him yet. If you check, the amount of editors up for editor of the year is the same as the one for most helpful (3127).

[LittleAtari]

I'll throw Shui in the ballot. When it comes down to suggesting songs and help with music in general, he's pretty much the best one to ask to.

speaking of the ballot, how is who gets to be on the ballot decided because i noticed that some of the people i wanted to nominate were not on it.

Any user eligible for VCAs should be in the most helpful list, actually. When i said ballot I just meant I'd put his nick in the thread since no one recommended him yet. If you check, the amount of editors up for editor of the year is the same as the one for most helpful (3127).

Well then one more question: What if said helpful member did not make a video this year? Does that effect their eligibility for most helpful? I obviously think that it shouldnt, but I'm wondering if you guys may have accidentally overlooked that.

[mirkosp]

Well then one more question: What if said helpful member did not make a video this year? Does that effect their eligibility for most helpful? I obviously think that it shouldnt, but I'm wondering if you guys may have accidentally overlooked that.

I have no clue honestly... John should reply to this one. Though I fear that might be the case.

[GloryQuestor]

We'll have to do this on a case-by-case basis. PM me with any members you would like to add to the list for your nomination.

[LittleAtari]

We'll have to do this on a case-by-case basis. PM me with any members you would like to add to the list for your nomination.

Thanks GQ. Please keep it in mind for next year so that we dont have to worry about it again ^^

[mirkosp]

We'll have to do this on a case-by-case basis. PM me with any members you would like to add to the list for your nomination.

Thanks GQ. Please keep it in mind for next year so that we dont have to worry about it again ^^

Actually he told me why they did it like that. It wasn't overlooked, just that making the contest opt-out, basically every member of the org would have been included in the most helpful ballot besides those that opted out. There are over 800k users right now so...
Perhaps next year we should make it so that it's opt out for those that haven't made vids, so that those can opt-in for most helpful and we won't have to worry about huge numbers.

[GloryQuestor]

As requested, Niotex and -Reda- have been added to the list so that they may qualify for 2010 VCA nomination in "Most Helpful Member". This announcement goes into more detail on what had to be done to make it work, so please review it and post here with any questions.

[Inan]

Niotex