P.O.E Season 3 : Round 1 - "The King of Spring"

[Iron Solari]

I liked #10, I am not sure what I can say about it other then the fact that it was definitely a summery feel-good video.

[Kitsuner]

I liked #10, I am not sure what I can say about it other then the fact that it was definitely a summery feel-good video.

It was also a good summery of the anime.

[sakuraslight]

Video opinions continued

5

Spoiler :

Great love hunt / drama AMV not much reference to seasons is the audio

6

Spoiler :

Nice i like good story the feects are well done and turning some summer ones into winter by reversing them and making them gray scale was a good choice ^^ would have like a but more AMV about it felt more end of a drama season on a TV show.

7

Spoiler :

Timing is good good choice of music i recognized it straight away but have always been a fan of that kind of music. fits realy well. i know you where trying to go for a remembrance AMV some of the cuts are a bit to hard for me. and the pic effects at 16 seconds looks a little unnatural compared to the rest of the AMV maby dropping the opacity would have sorted that out a bit better.

8

Spoiler :

summer is all over the AMV. I associate this kind of song with boys making trouble. some of the zooms are blocky . and spoil it. lip sync is off cuts are all over the place. where i expect there to be cuts to the beats there are non. also a very sudden end.

9

Spoiler :

quality could be alot better can see alot of bandding and blocking. love the story to it though. i know you have cut the song early..but was expecting it to kick in to something a bit more. also sounds like you may have slowed it down a little more than it was original. (but will have to find the original audio to check that. looks like a murder story more than a seasons AMV. liked it but needs more spit shine

10

Spoiler :

Good song, good anime Very fun, Very seasonal Very musical. good story.. best one i have seen so far.
Lip sync looks a little unfinished on some of the minor parts. the off aspect stuff with the flower bands is horrid. keep the or remove them they keep changing and putting me off the AMV. and the End is very over the to and i get a residual image of bolts from a bridge... timing is spot on... Fave so far for music choice good but reminds me of grease to much

11

Spoiler :

Someone has a thing for heat. good summer AMV pulls out the laziness of hot summer days. quality is good. a little lacking in the sceans department. but fits the music well.

Thats it for now...

[CodeZTM]

Let video 12 wrap up your winter blues!

Video 13 is ready to "spring" into action!

Video 14 is here to to put your day in motion!

Video 15 is here for your snowy pleasure.

[Animated]

JUDGEMENT TIME! Let's give some harsh opinions, shall we?? I'll also write down my thoughts on whether it should pass to the next round or fails

1

Spoiler :

Use ALL the snow scenes! Basic editing, wrong aspect ratios here and there, it was all about... snow, easy concept. It was like "cool scene", "next cool winter scene", "another cool snow scene" etc. Probably passes to the next round.

2

Spoiler :

...ok this had nothing to do with the theme given. The theme was taken as an excuse to do a battle amv. Anyway, basic editing once again, I'd say it will fail to pass to the next round due to the lack of Theme Points.

3

Spoiler :

I really don't get this one. Girls running, sleeping, playing the guitars, running again, group hugs... Winter? I don't get it. Maybe passes to the next round.

4

Spoiler :

ABRUPT SONG CUT! Why. You could have just ended it there with a smoother fadeout. But it was very nice till that part, I'd say it passes :3

5

Spoiler :

I don't get this one either! Where is the summer concept?! Good editing but nothing to do with the theme! URGH! Even after reading the editor's comments, i still don't get what it has to do with the theme given! 50-50, dunno if it passes or fails

6

Spoiler :

This guy/girl should really have some typography lessons. Apart from that, a pretty cool relaxing video. I'd say it passes.

7

Spoiler :

Well, that surely passes to the next round. A nice concept, nice idea, pretty editing, great song selection.

8

Spoiler :

This one should have been longer. But still, even if it was bigger, i wouldn't give it high chances of passing to the next round. Girls, boobs, and hardcuts. On the first round where the 1/3 of us is eliminated, only the strongest survive!

9

Spoiler :

If i hadn't read the editor's comments, I would not understand the concept behind this. But now I do. WHY DIDN'T YOU EDIT THE AWESOME CHORUS PART!!! You... damn brat! It's like getting a 2.000$ computer, just to play Minesweeper!! I wanted to edit to this song in the next round, and now I can't!

Passes to the next round.

10

Spoiler :

Here's a guy that put some effort in his video! You deserve to win this contest, you took Project Editor seriously. 100% passes to the next round

11

Spoiler :

And here I present you the laziest editor of them all If I were a judge, i'd pass this to the next round, just because of it's clever concept. Apart from that... slowpoke mode ON

12

Spoiler :

Just when I thought "hey, this is the most fitting song till now for this theme, but no editing at all"... GOD MY EYES AND MY EARS, THEY BLEED.

13

Spoiler :

There was something wrong with this video. One of the anime didn't blend at all with the other ones. I don't know if it's Pokemon or 5cm, but the outcome was weird. The kind of editing you used didn't help also, you were just depending on some pretty scenes. I'd say it fails to get to the next round, and that's a pity because the song was fitting perfectly for a spring vid.

14

Spoiler :

Pretty scene after pretty scene after pretty scene. And you kinda overdid it with 5cm per second... Second half was kinda better than the first one, but still I wouldn't give that high chances of passing to the next round too, sorry

15

Spoiler :

After seeing lots and lots of 5cm scenes till now... A full 5cm video! Nothing special, only crossfades and a cute song. You really have to try harder to get to the next round, it was just... average. I'd say it fails.

[afanador]

I'll be livestreaming while I'm watching/judging all these videos and giving some basic critique and feedback sometime this weekend. I'll post links when it begins.

Have you started yet? Do you have a link or something?

[NS]

This weekend, as in after the deadline most likely

[Animated]

...no one cares about the videos, everyone just wants Shin's livestreaming!

[CodeZTM]

Video 16 is up, and it's time to Remember us some Decembers!

Also, if we get ONE more video, we'll have a first in Project OrgEditor history. The first time we have <50% round 1 drops.

[pacotacoshell]

Vid 12: Not many words I can express here....>__>
Vid 13: This vid would have been 1000% better if you didn't use 5cm per second. The Pokemon source was refreshing, and it was paired with Origin SO WELL. But then you have this overused, unfitting 5cm sitting in the derp corner taking all the space.
Vid 14: You had some fun sync on a few parts, but overall it felt pretty lazy in terms of scene selection and sync across the board. Not to mention I didn't feel the bass drop AT ALL ;____;
Vid 15: The song/anime combination is good and it fits, but an idea like this isn't gonna get you very far in the contest.

And let me just tell you right now that using 5CM in this round is boring as hell :l There is so much better anime you could use, like Hoshi wo ou Kodomo or Origins Spirits of the Past if you just want to use pretty scenes all day.