moonie211 wrote:
Forgive me for asking something that has already been asked and posted before
but are we suppose to leave a second of black screen at the start of the video?
I noticed some other betas were done that way.
Mine was edited right at the start but It can be changed easily.
Nope its fine. I honestly dont see the point of having black at the beginning and end because a coordinator can add that themself if they need to o_O
anywaii i shall critique betas that have been uploaded! O:
Addy: Im gonna need you to have a scene at the beginning from the very start of the track without any black so i can make a smoother transition ;O anyways you rushed it so it isnt anything amazing. It nice to know that you've at least started your track so im sure itll look better when i get more betas from you.
Katie: Looking awesome so far~ lots of colors, good font choice for the words at the beginning ;O I really like what you've done at 0:51, maybe itd be cool if you did the same thing at 1:04 (just for consistency.. and its cool xD) my only gripe would be that at 0:33 - 0:35 the panning in the background moves a little too fast which disrupts the flow a little bit. But besides that..
Moonie: I love the synching you've got going on, you're always good with this kind of stuff. Good job! Plus, you added FSN.. add moar of it 8D anyways it looks pretty cool. The only thing that bugs me is at the beginning, the synching is moving wayyy too fast for the music to keep up. Maybe you could have a prolonged fade in at the beginning or something. That and some of the old-school sources kind of clash with the newer stuff you're using (namely at 0:05, 0:22 and 0:23) So basically just slow down the beginning a little bit, maybe replace the old school scenes... and add moar FSN
Scoob: Prettyyyy, ive never seen Kiddy Grade but dangit its pretty. And you added another one of those manga things at the beginning, good stuff. The only thing id suggest would be to change the scene at the end because it seems pretty static in comparison to the beginning. Basically that and the bass in the background demands some kind of sync. Maybe you could make the bars flash or something. I dont know, just a suggestion x3
SSJ: Good stuffs~ synching was spot on for the most part. The only thing id nitpick on editing wise would be the camera movement at 0:01 - 0:02 sec, it looks a little awkward for some reason. I really like what you did at 0:05 - 0:07 btw, dont change it ;O anyways great job with your editing. The only thing id nitpick about isnt necessarily the editing or anything but the sources used. Clannad and EF work together very nicely but Amazing Nuts, while the animation is definitely on par, the character designs just clash a bit. Of course thats probably just personal taste xD Im not asking you to take it out or anything, just maybe you could add a bit of it at the beginning of the track or something so it meshes together a bit more with the other sources. Anyways, besides that, good work, keep it up!
Anyways ive heard from pretty much everyone about betas
except Rina, Eva, and Marko.
YOUR BETAS, WHERE DEY AT?
