S U F F U S E

[EvaFan]

Some parts felt a bit too slow, and I personally wasn't able to enjoy it too much, but that's for a personal taste matter. Good stuff you got there, 4/5.

For some reason I felt the exact opposite. I really liked the slow parts. They seemed to set the mood and overall ambience better to the music. Felt like the pacing got out of hand once the motion and scene switching picked up. Killed the mood a bit there but it was still really enjoyable. I think if I was to of listened to this song for the first time without watching this video... Wouldn't of liked it but this video presented the songs "color" so to speak. Good stuff. This was kind of a shocker comparably speaking to how fun/upbeat all the other video's I've seen from re-evo members but I'm gonna guess I haven't seen that many. If you 2 are the members that usually make the dark/drama vids then I look forward to your next release .

4/5

[Elcalavero]

After all the positive comments above,
I was expecting something epic.
I guess I set my exceptions too high.
There were too many parts where the pacing got out of hand.
Flawless editing from 0:00 to 0:56 however, everything went downhill after that.
Nice music, Mediocre amv

5/10

[Animated]

Lovely. As hell.

4/5

[bladedude101]

After all the positive comments above,
I was expecting something epic.
I guess I set my exceptions too high.
There were too many parts where the pacing got out of hand.
Flawless editing from 0:00 to 0:56 however, everything went downhill after that.
Nice music, Mediocre amv

5/10

While everyone is entitled to their own opinion and I agree that the video was a little inconsistent in the flow, I feel that your rating is extremely harsh. 5/10 isn't even quiet mediocre, that falls more into a poor category and if you can honestly watch this and say the editing is poor, I think you need to redefine your opinion of how editing works. I can't imagine how you'd rate an actual poor amv.

On subject.

This amv was great, one of the best re-evo amvs produced yet. It had some minor inconsitency issues and it looks like the source footage or maybe the style of anime isn't that high quality, but it still came out with above average quality. The editing was mostly solid and the idea was original and greatly enjoyable.

Since we apparently rate out of 10 now with increased font.


9/10

[LittleAtari]

After all the positive comments above,
I was expecting something epic.
I guess I set my exceptions too high.
There were too many parts where the pacing got out of hand.
Flawless editing from 0:00 to 0:56 however, everything went downhill after that.
Nice music, Mediocre amv

5/10

While everyone is entitled to their own opinion and I agree that the video was a little inconsistent in the flow, I feel that your rating is extremely harsh. 5/10 isn't even quiet mediocre, that falls more into a poor category and if you can honestly watch this and say the editing is poor, I think you need to redefine your opinion of how editing works. I can't imagine how you'd rate an actual poor amv.

On subject.

This amv was great, one of the best re-evo amvs produced yet. It had some minor inconsitency issues and it looks like the source footage or maybe the style of anime isn't that high quality, but it still came out with above average quality. The editing was mostly solid and the idea was original and greatly enjoyable.

Since we apparently rate out of 10 now with increased font.


9/10

LittleAtari's Guide to the Org - Chapter 1:
Dont listen to Elcalavero

On the video, I liked it. The only thing that I would say was a down point was that it was too consistent in how it was edited and synced. Next time, change it up a little and it will grab the attention of your viewer more.
Still a nice video 4/5

[Stratos-RvS]

yes yes very good amv, transmit a dark and gloomy atmosphere i like it,good job 4,5/5

[Elcalavero]

.
I think a certain young lady is trying to come on to me.

While everyone is entitled to their own opinion and I agree that the video was a little inconsistent in the flow, I feel that your rating is extremely harsh. 5/10 isn't even quiet mediocre, that falls more into a poor category and if you can honestly watch this and say the editing is poor, I think you need to redefine your opinion of how editing works. I can't imagine how you'd rate an actual poor amv.

Yes it is my opinion, nothing you do or say will change it. The creator(s) can disregard my opinion if they so choose to do so.

Since we apparently rate out of 10 now with increased font.


9/10

So first you tell me to redefine how my opinion on editing works,
then you go ahead and rate this video THE WAY I RATED IT. Clear proof that your a God Damn Moron.

[Inan]

.
I think a certain young lady is trying to come on to me.

While everyone is entitled to their own opinion and I agree that the video was a little inconsistent in the flow, I feel that your rating is extremely harsh. 5/10 isn't even quiet mediocre, that falls more into a poor category and if you can honestly watch this and say the editing is poor, I think you need to redefine your opinion of how editing works. I can't imagine how you'd rate an actual poor amv.

Yes it is my opinion, nothing you do or say will change it. The creator(s) can disregard my opinion if they so choose to do so.

Since we apparently rate out of 10 now with increased font.


9/10

So first you tell me to redefine how my opinion on editing works,
then you go ahead and rate this video THE WAY I RATED IT. Clear proof that your a God Damn Moron.

[bladedude101]

.
I think a certain young lady is trying to come on to me.

While everyone is entitled to their own opinion and I agree that the video was a little inconsistent in the flow, I feel that your rating is extremely harsh. 5/10 isn't even quiet mediocre, that falls more into a poor category and if you can honestly watch this and say the editing is poor, I think you need to redefine your opinion of how editing works. I can't imagine how you'd rate an actual poor amv.

Yes it is my opinion, nothing you do or say will change it. The creator(s) can disregard my opinion if they so choose to do so.

Since we apparently rate out of 10 now with increased font.


9/10

So first you tell me to redefine how my opinion on editing works,
then you go ahead and rate this video THE WAY I RATED IT. Clear proof that your a God Damn Moron.

Where common sense lacks so does the ability to notice satire apparently.

I made one small comment in disagreement with your opinion of the amv in an non-bashful and polite respectful manner, and you reply with large letters and very third grade based insult. Thanks for your time.

You might as well not reply to this, I wont reply to anything you say and it wouldn't be fair to turn MJSisters's thread into a bitchfight over something as silly as me being a moron. Cheerios.

[DaikashiSan]

For those who haven't seen this video yet:

1. Grab some popcorn.
2. Download this video.
3. Set your alarms for 12:00 AM.
4. Watch the video.
5. Shit yourself with joy. It is a great video, and deserves to be critiqued.

- My Critiques -
Overall everything is great. Quality could be have been better had it been exported in a different method, and I'll guide you through that before your next video. Right now, besides what has already been stated about minor syncs, I can't really say at all that this video has any other downfall. It had decent music... not my cup of tea, but it works very well with Le Portrait De Petit Cossette.

The atmosphere(scenes with mild movement/omninous feels to it) was pretty well in play the full time through the AMV which was good. There were some odd syncs at times but I really can't complain, some of those random attempts might've actually spiced up the video a bit which kept it from ever turning dull.

Nothing else that I can really add except: terrific job on your first video on the org and I do hope to see more from you ladies.