irrelevant
this is completely biased towards your opinions, and deciding that most of the org edits for "popularity" (just because you may edit for improper reasons doesn't mean you can legitimately speak for the rest of the community) is not too advertent, and frankly is coming off as pretentious. but entertaining others? perhaps, but that doesn't exclude entertaining their own self.It reminds me of the old days when people actually still had fun making amvs
personally, i had more fun editing to the amv i'm currently in the progress of than i ever had in the entire time i've had this as a hobby. "old days"? obviously it's still present.
relevant
okay, this was a pretty nice and simple amv.
it was synced nicely for the most part. the color correctors sorta' bothered me, along with the fading/black flashing here and there. also the blur around 1:46 was oddly placed, and it didn't seem to alter as the scene went on, although there was panning on it as well that could have been a bit more smoothly applied. the glows; it'd of been nice if they would've last longer on the scenes that had them but it's not really too significant.
the crossfades were all used pretty nicely. i also liked how you kept a bit going after the song ended. there wasn't too much to criticize about. the syncing could have been more thorough throughout certain segments but maybe that's just my personal preference. the amv didn't necessarily stand out to me, but it's nice to see simplicity.
i viewed it as an obligation to respond to a certain amusement. funny how you pushed the argument to an ending and altered you tone just because you got boggled down with more than one person and couldn't handle.
