Project NeoEditor [Results - Aug 11, 2010 01:00 AM CST]

[MycathatesyouAMV]

Honestly I am really puzzled by Judge A's scores. 18 points in originality for HazeFM and a 1 for Visual Quality and 9 points in accurate tribute for my vid ? Placements were messed up this round. Arashinome I though shouldve been higher and Haze at 3rd Wtf ?

[Enigma]

Oh well

[CodeZTM]

Project NeoEditor Round 3
-Smiles and Tears

______________

The Premise

Video games have often had a specific medium that other forms of art have a hard time incorporating. Video games have the ability to take us from fantastically happy, to terribly sad to utterly devastated and then take us back to a great and happy ending. Incorporating this into AMV's is something that the truely elite are capable of doing and doing to a fantastic point.


______________

Premise Meaning

As stated above, being able to combine varying aspects of emotions and transitioning them from one and other in a great fashion is an important editing skill for the great editors to have. Going from one spectrum to another is a great way to tell a emotionally riveting ability.

______________

The Round

Being able to transition from the emotional elements and combine them into one AMV is an important and elite skill that all should have and be capapble of utilizing to create amazing AMV's.

For this round, create an AMV that begins with the utmost happiness, transitions to utter devastation and depression. But in the end, the AMV is capableABLE of having a happy and/or sentimental ending.

Judging Criteria for Execution of Theme
50 Points for Covering the 3 emotional spectrums
______________

Special Round Related Rules

1) Please name your file "Round 3 Entry #" when sending it to me.

Chez's Choice Award
Chez's Choice

[MycathatesyouAMV]

what do u mean by capable of a happy ending ?

[CodeZTM]

what do u mean by capable of a happy ending ?

fine. ABLE of having a happy ending.

[NS]

I know which judge I am in the list

edit: haze's video may have sucked.. but in the judging criteria it fit everything, I marked him down on sync because the lip sync was lazy as hell..

edit again: actually pretty happy to see the final results were pretty in line with my opinions. >_>

[MycathatesyouAMV]

I know which judge I am in the list

edit: haze's video may have sucked.. but in the judging criteria it fit everything, I marked him down on sync because the lip sync was lazy as hell..

edit again: actually pretty happy to see the final results were pretty in line with my opinions. >_>

Kinda might mean the criteria is a little unbalanced though, no ?

[Enigma]

For this round, create an AMV that begins with the utmost happiness, transitions to utter devastation and depression. But in the end, the AMV is capableABLE of having a happy and/or sentimental ending.

Atleast it's not an IC

[CodeZTM]

I know which judge I am in the list

edit: haze's video may have sucked.. but in the judging criteria it fit everything, I marked him down on sync because the lip sync was lazy as hell..

edit again: actually pretty happy to see the final results were pretty in line with my opinions. >_>

Kinda might mean the criteria is a little unbalanced though, no ?

If you have any suggestions for how the judging criteria could be improved upon, I am more than open to suggestions for future events.

[NS]

I know which judge I am in the list

edit: haze's video may have sucked.. but in the judging criteria it fit everything, I marked him down on sync because the lip sync was lazy as hell..

edit again: actually pretty happy to see the final results were pretty in line with my opinions. >_>

Kinda might mean the criteria is a little unbalanced though, no ?

eh, I don't think so. Reda was being a troll, and haze went with it, it sucks but if the roles were flipped you wouldn't be complaining.

edit: it's kinda funny, you can tell which one is code... he's so nice :3