I'm mainly a fan of the scene selection, and in conjunction, the atmosphere. It was very well done in that regard, and I have no complaints. The sync was also very nice, and not as boring as I would have expected an amv to be to this song. Also, nice job in choosing which scenes to have voiceovers on-- I really like them, but people often put them in the worst of places.
When it got to 2:39 though, I cringed a little. The concept just got really cliche to me, and some of the statistics I didn't like (particularly the whole "x babies born every second, x babies born every minute." Same thing with the deaths, I don't think it's necessarily to have them both, as they're pretty much the same thing. And the "while 1 scientist is creating a weapon, 1 million moms are baking cakes," that one was just... blech. And while I liked the snow statistic, it seemed really irrelevant to the theme and concept.) It was too obvious to me, and I think it was too black and white and too sudden.
But I like the fact that there was a concept, even if I didn't like the concept that much.
Any amv that at least has a good atmosphere is solid, no matter the editing or concept flaws, in my opinion. Still, my criticism stands. But despite all that, I think it was really good.
)
...
