The Critical Eye

[Sederien]

Welcome to The Critical Eye. This topic is dedicated to those who want an honest, critical opinion on their work. Please note that, like The Critic, this is a volunteer operation by one person and should be treated as such (I.E. reviews are subject to real life time constraints ^_^).

Here are the general guidelines. There are no real rules.

1. To keep things fair, opinions are given on a first come first serve basis with the following exception. If you have donated to a-m-v.org (as indicated by the Donation: Donated to the left), your video will be moved to the top of the list. Thank you for supporting such a wonderful site.

2. If your video has spoilers it is quite possible that I won't review it. Please understand that unless I've seen the anime (and I've seen a good number), it really detracts from my enjoyment of a series if I know who killed who.

3. Please be kind to your fellow creators (and critics) and only post one video per couple of days if you really want more than one reviewed.

4. Reviews take time. I may never get to yours. Sad truth as it may be. Thank you for your patience.

Happy Posting.

[Joykiller]

I'd love for you to check out my newest vid, Super (Freaky Hero)! The link is in the sig

Thanks!

[Sederien]

The Critical Eye Hall of Fame

Every so often I will induct certain members into a top ten video list reviewed through The Critical Eye. The first inductee was not actually reviewed here, but it's more of an honorary membership, per se.

1. VicBond007's Die Another Day

That's the one to top folks.

Happy Posting.

[Jnzk]

1. VicBond007's Die Another Day

That's the one to top folks.

My video definitely won't top THAT, but at least it's the same anime. An opinion on this would be much appreciated:

http://www.animemusicvideos.org/members ... hp?v=38938

Thank you for doing this service to the community.

[Brain-Carnival]

Here's my newest:

http://www.animemusicvideos.org/members ... hp?v=38861

Thx!!!

[Sederien]

I'd love for you to check out my newest vid, Super (Freaky Hero)! The link is in the sig

Thanks!

Done!

[Sederien]

1. VicBond007's Die Another Day

That's the one to top folks.

My video definitely won't top THAT, but at least it's the same anime. An opinion on this would be much appreciated:

http://www.animemusicvideos.org/members ... hp?v=38938

Thank you for doing this service to the community.

Thank you for the kind comment. Your video's reviewed.

[Joykiller]

I'd love for you to check out my newest vid, Super (Freaky Hero)! The link is in the sig

Thanks!

Done!

Thanks!! Awesome review! You included alot of very useful insight. I appreciate it. If I would have known that Perfect Blue was one of your favorite anime, I would have suggested my other vid. Well maybe next week I can bring that one up for ya!

[theocide]

ouw. i got one for you

http://www.animemusicvideos.org/members ... hp?v=31645

[Sederien]

Here's my newest:

http://www.animemusicvideos.org/members ... hp?v=38861

Thx!!!

You're all set. The rest of the requests will have to wait for tonight, but since there aren't any currently, send them in!

Joykiller - I'll add the Perfect Blue one to the list, but I'll handle any that come in later today/tomorrow first. Thanks for the comment (it means a lot) and glad I could help out.