stolen amv footage!!

killerkitty · Post by **killerkitty** » Wed Dec 01, 2004 3:34 pm

not sure why everyone is yelling. ripping dvs and distributing them is illegal. even more so is the music added. no one owns the videos here. only the ones who own the copyright.

http://www.musicunited.org/2_thelaw.html#2

killerkitty · Post by **killerkitty** » Wed Dec 01, 2004 3:36 pm

Oh My wrote:I don't see anything wrong with using some clips from other people's AMVs...what if your comp is too crappy to hold all the eps you want? as long as they don't steal your idea, I wouldn't worry...

one time I saw an Inuyasha-Disturbed video that was done incredibley well, COMPLETELY the same video put to Adema's Immortal song...now that is horrid...

my friends have used clips from my AMVs cause they couldn't find them anywhere else

yeah wait till amv locks your video for that.

Hypershadow23 · Post by **Hypershadow23** » Wed Dec 01, 2004 3:47 pm

damn. That sucks. I may be new, but I dont steal footage from other creators. Thats just wrong. But what are ya gana do....
You could find the guy and hack into him or somethin. I dont know.. Sorry to hear that though.

Pyle · Post by **Pyle** » Wed Dec 01, 2004 3:58 pm

killerkitty wrote:not sure why everyone is yelling. ripping dvs and distributing them is illegal. even more so is the music added. no one owns the videos here. only the ones who own the copyright.

http://www.musicunited.org/2_thelaw.html#2

Marry me. Right now. PLEASE!

killerkitty · Post by **killerkitty** » Wed Dec 01, 2004 3:59 pm

haha funny pyle!

Undertow · Post by **Undertow** » Wed Dec 01, 2004 4:35 pm

killerkitty wrote:haha funny pyle!

It could be he's serious, a major asshat like you is a rare find, something to treasure i'm sure

Radman · Post by **Radman** » Thu Dec 02, 2004 5:11 am

I have an awesome idea for an AMV. However, to be polite, I took the liberty of seeing if it had been used already. It has been used once. (the same song to the same anime)....
Before I continue- If I were to still make an AMV with the same anime and song, would that be terribly bad?

Moving onward, I took the liberty of watching this person's AMV. Although the AMV was alright, some scenes put to different parts of the lyrics seem so good that I seriously consider using those same scenes (from my own DVDs) in my AMV.
Would this be grossly wrong or impolite as well?

badmartialarts · Post by **badmartialarts** » Thu Dec 02, 2004 7:15 am

It becomes a question of ethics. I'm not sure about your case, but I'll illustrate mine. I was listening to the song "Comfort Eagle" by Cake and thought "Man, it would be cool to do a crossover between Lain and Cowboy Bebop with this song! There's the one ep of Cowboy Bebop with the digital religion, and then use Lain footage! It'll be great!" Except, there are two videos to "Comfort Eagle", one using just Cowboy Bebop, and one using just Lain.

So, it becomes a problem. I don't wanna detract from their vids (which are pretty good, especially the Lain one). So, I set the idea aside and moved on....

mvmarcz · Post by **mvmarcz** » Thu Dec 02, 2004 12:51 pm

Radman wrote:I have an awesome idea for an AMV. However, to be polite, I took the liberty of seeing if it had been used already. It has been used once. (the same song to the same anime)....
Before I continue- If I were to still make an AMV with the same anime and song, would that be terribly bad?

Moving onward, I took the liberty of watching this person's AMV. Although the AMV was alright, some scenes put to different parts of the lyrics seem so good that I seriously consider using those same scenes (from my own DVDs) in my AMV.
Would this be grossly wrong or impolite as well?

the way I see it you already had the idea and it was similar to someone else's right? Try to find a way to make it unique to you and if it has similar elements so what? If your using your own footage and your own idea balls to anyone who jumps on your case for thinking like someone else did.
I'd make it and make it my own.

Undertow · Post by **Undertow** » Thu Dec 02, 2004 1:03 pm

Radman wrote:I have an awesome idea for an AMV. However, to be polite, I took the liberty of seeing if it had been used already. It has been used once. (the same song to the same anime)....
Before I continue- If I were to still make an AMV with the same anime and song, would that be terribly bad?

Moving onward, I took the liberty of watching this person's AMV. Although the AMV was alright, some scenes put to different parts of the lyrics seem so good that I seriously consider using those same scenes (from my own DVDs) in my AMV.
Would this be grossly wrong or impolite as well?

I did the same thing, i had a pretty good idea of what i wanted to do, and checked out if it was already there, and it was. Fortunatly the other idea sucked badly, so i had the perfect opportunity to do it right.
For those who don't know what i'm refering to, it's my Same Old Song video and Circ-A's I love ... Akira !!!. I hope everyone can agree with me that mine is a but better, atleast i hope everyone can. But as you can see, no problem in doing the same idea as someone else did, the only problem is when you do something that has been done 10 times before (linkin' park/DBZ), but i doubt your planning on doing that

AnimeMusicVideos.org

stolen amv footage!!

the idea

Re: the idea

Re: the idea