It's not unstated. Quoting from <a href="http://www.animemusicvideos.org/banners/">here</a>:Arigatomina wrote:Right, but there's some sort of unstated clause that lets members of this site take that logo, alter it, and submit it on their banners, which they're also free to use on their personal websites.
As far as using the banners go, it's kinda vauge. The only thing that page really says about use is:Banner ads must contain the official logo somewhere on the ad or at some time during the ad. You can use the example image or the original Adobe Illustrator source (links below).
The phrasing implies permission is given to use banners (and therefore the logo since it MUST be on the banner) for linking to the site and nothing else. If unsure, we can go to the generic 'If you have any questions, please contact the site admin' part although we already have the site admins answer.Worthy banner ads may be used by anyone to link to this site.
Technically and legally speaking, as far as Phade specifically gives permission for and not an inch more. Realistically you could get away with it, it just isn't worth the cost and time to fight assuming Phade ever learned about it to begin with. I suspect the org members reaction would be even more extreme than it is to video theft though.Arigatomina wrote:What I was asking was how far the 'free use' goes for members.
Well, that's enough of the contest rules. My personal take on it is that there would be valid concerns on if the money would actually reach the org. While I'm sure SarahtheBoring is upfront and honest about her request that doesn't mean everyone would be. If you let anyone use the logo for profit then someone somewhere will realize that hey, Phade doesn't know how many buttons they sold, why not only donate half the profit and keep half?
I think some sort of arrangement where Phade designates a trusted source to act as the orgs collection guy at major cons would work. After all, the admins and mods attend many cons and they're already trusted by the org so why not ask if they'd accept the responsability of collecting money? Permission would have to be sought for selling org products then the trusted source could gather the profits during the con (and take donations as well). If no trusted source is attending the con, or willing to accept responsability for the cash, then permission would be denied for using the logo at that con. This would allow major cons to have someone accepting donations or selling org products without leaving use of the logo totally open to anyone who wants to make a quick buck or two.