

I definitely know how you feel... and it's discouraging to repeatedly not make the finals while seeing the same names pop up over and over... it's hard not to wonder if you just aren't good enough... but, contests like these are extremely subjective. It's just based on whatever the judges personally like. Sometimes whether you get in or not just depends on what the other entries are like. Maybe your entry is really good, but there's a lot of really good videos in that category, so yours just doesn't make it. I try to keep all that kind of stuff in mind and not feel like I failed somehow when I don't make it into contests. I just hope people get to see the videos. But, I think it's okay to want to make videos both for yourself and for others. It doesn't have to be totally for fun. Striving for contests encourages you to do your best work and try new things, and I don't think that's a bad thing, or that it's wrong to hope your effort pays off.Sephirothskr wrote:I often make the videos for my viewers and fans on youtube and the org as much as I do for myself. So, it sometimes makes me feel pressured that the videos have to be fantastic. You know?
I always try to do this ^ngsilver wrote: I, and I'm sure it's the same for everyone else, am my own harshest critic. So when I do feel down or left out after seeing another round of contests I submitted videos to either deny the entry for whatever reason or pick other entries over mine to be shown at con I just gotta remind myself that the reason I made the video wasn't for others to watch it, it was for me.
Thanks NG. That's so true. I'm going to be a film major so sometimes I'm torn between an AMV and making a real life music video again... there's this one song I REAAALLLY want to do where no music video or amv exists for it, and it'd be neat to do either way.ngsilver wrote:I've been quoted time and again for this... "Edit what you want to edit. Don't listen to anyone else." (well, maybe not that exact phrase but close enough)
I don't think I've won an award at a contest (other then beating other staffers at youmacon) in a good half decade at least. When I did win awards and frequently make it into contests it was for my animated gif videos and if you listen to popular opinion on those they are not even AMVs. When I make something I'm passionate about and not just making for fun (See Go or last year's AWA Pro entry Drive vs the Dance series) the videos rarely make it into showings at-con, let alone competition, and when they do most people just don't get them, understand them, or like them. But alas, I keep doing it.
Sure. I suppose it'd be nice to win awards. heck, even have the videos shown at cons so people can actually see the videos and maybe like them would be nice. But in the end I make what I want to make because that's the kind of video I want to see at that time. If no one else likes or cares about it then that's fine cuz' I just added to the list of videos I want to exist.
I, and I'm sure it's the same for everyone else, am my own harshest critic. So when I do feel down or left out after seeing another round of contests I submitted videos to either deny the entry for whatever reason or pick other entries over mine to be shown at con I just gotta remind myself that the reason I made the video wasn't for others to watch it, it was for me.